Dear brother Guhar,

I have seen on Kashnet that so-called pro Pakistan people analyses the views by pro Indian and pro independence as Indian agents, irrespective of their origin, their stand and their arguments. If some thing is not anti Indian, or directed against the Pakistani adminstration or AK government, it must be pro Indian. Not only you, but the other people who are continuously on net and keen looking for such posts.  Now you people have almost monopoly on kashnet and you would like to dictate the people what they should write and whom they should condemn. Brother if you are facing atrocities, that is your legitimate and birth right to raise the voice against these atrocities and to condemn them. I am totally agree with you.  But on the same way, the people who have similar problems with Pakistani administrations, Pakistani government and Pakistani police and army, the have similar and the same rights as you have.  Please consider them also as a human being at first and kashmiri at second level. If you are a genuine kashmiri and has suffering, you would understand my feelings and my words.

Like pro Pakistan, there are also pro Indian Kashmiri lobby. In the same way there are also a huge number of pro Independence people, please don’t try to push all the eggs in one basket. This is the history, the vast majority of the Kashmiri people were pro Indian and they elected Sheikh Muhammad Abdullah and his politics. At that time, we, the pro independence fraction were also working for a unified and independent Kashmir. In that critical time, the than Pakistani administration put Maqbool Butt Shaheed and his companions into Jails and they remained there more are less ten years in Pakistani jails and tortured there. Ultimately, the supreme Court of Pakistan released them and declare them as freedom fighters.  At that time all you people were enjoying the hospitalities of Indian government.

This is a very tragic in the history of Kashmir, that the different groups accuse one another as traitors and the agents of India and Pakistan. Don’t you think, that there are some people who are working for their nation, for their home land? Why an anti Pakistan must be pro Indian or a pro Pakistan must be anti Indian. We can have different schools of thought.  If you belong to Indian and you see Indian atrocities in your daily life, you can adopt an anti Indian and or pro Pakistan stand. In the same way, the peoples  who belongs to Pakistani occupied Kashmir and are facing problems there, they can react in accordance.  The main and the common thing between us that we are SLAVES of India and Pakistan and facing atrocities. If you like Pakistan, there is always an option for you to cross the control line and start living in Pakistan or in AK. You will see the reality with your own open eyes.

Once I was also a preacher of Pakistan and was very proud to be Pakistani, but please come to Pakistan, live there one year as a common Pakistani and then argue on net, I will wel come your views, but surely you will be a very changed person. There you would find burocratic fascism, religious fascism, political fascism and every kind of Fascisms which exist any where.  I really love ordinary Pakistani, they are very sweet and innocent people. I will not say any thing more than that. Shabir Chaudhry is in the same way a Pakistani Kashmiri and he try to tell you people the profile, the other side of the mirror!!!!   Thre is no difference between this and that. We are slaves and we have to fight for our freedom and reunifications.

You must not agree with me, but please respect the opinions of other people of your nation.